[If you think he looks creepy, well he's got his own opinion on you. Why, you're the strangest pony he's ever seen!]

I'm afraid I must beg yours!

[He glides closer, both mismatched eyes focused on this new person.]

I've never seen anything like you before! Walking on two legs and hardly any fur on you! Where's your tail even?

[He circles around Sherlock, but his body is so long and serpentine that he very nearly traps the man, though certainly with enough room to move.]

Come on now, I'm dying to know!